Journal-Times (Grayson, KY)

Local News

December 12, 2012

Judge rules in Fiscal Court’s favor

Dec. 12, 2012 — A special judge has handed down a ruling in the Renee Stewart and Carter County Attorney Patrick Flannery vs. Carter County Fiscal Court dispute over open meetings.

Judge John David Preston of Johnson, Martin, and Lawrence counties presided at the bench trial on Nov. 29.

After a full day of testimony, Preston ruled against Stewart and Flannery in a judgment handed down on Dec. 6.

In his ruling, Preston sited another Open Meeting Violation case, Knox County vs. Hammons, which ruled that the Knox County Fiscal Court held its meeting at “such inconvenient locations as to effectively render public participation impossible.”

When taking that case into account, Preston concluded that with regard to the statutory language, as a matter of law that the Carter County Fiscal Court violated the Open Meetings Act, and that adjournment to the much larger old Circuit Courtroom would have been feasible.

However, Preston also took into account case law on the issue, which says the burden imposed on the plaintiffs, in this case Renee Stewart and Carter County Attorney Patrick Flannery, is extraordinarily high.

Preston said in his ruling that the case law states that Open Meetings statutes are designed to prevent government bodies from rendering public participation “impossible.”

Because the plaintiffs, Stewart and Flannery, were unable to meet the “impossibility standard,” they lost the case.

Carter County Jailer R.W. Boggs said the ruling would lead to more turmoil in Carter County.

“This case shows Wallace’s determination to shove the regional jail down the throats of the citizens despite the overwhelming majority of people who are against it,” Boggs said. “He has absolutely lost touch with the will of those who elected him to office.

Flannery believes that the ruling goes against the spirit of the Open Meetings Act.

“They are saying that a public agency can have a meeting in a broom closet if they want and that the Open Meetings Act has no teeth,” Flannery said. “This is a concern for anyone who has an interest in local government.”

Text Only
Local News
  • wreck.JPG US 60 closed

    August 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • Olive Hill water line breaks

    August 14, 2014

  • Teen killed in Wednesday crash

    August 13, 2014

  • Fiscal Court seeks to borrow $1.5 million for roads

    Carter Fiscal Court met last Tuesday night to consider borrowing money for a massive road resurfacing project.

    August 13, 2014

  • Nikki Lewis.JPG Lewis named CCA administrator

    School kicks off today at Carter Christian Academy at Hitchins. The private school is welcoming a new administrator, Nikki Lewis.

    August 13, 2014 1 Photo

  • Grayson emergency.jpg Grayson’s emergency help now on the air

    When future emergencies require volunteers to assist first responders in Grayson, no one should be out of communications, thanks to help from the Carter County Community Fund (CCCF).

    August 13, 2014 1 Photo

  • brooke.jpg Local girl featured in Reba McEntire video

    Brooke Seagraves didn't think she stood much of a chance of appearing in Reba McEntire's latest music video but that didn't stop her older sister from entering her name.

    August 13, 2014 1 Photo

  • Dive 1.jpg Dive training a success

    They owe it all to community support. The Grayson Fire Department's Rescue and Recovery Dive team is seeing huge improvements, thanks to a community that is behind them 100 percent.

    August 13, 2014 3 Photos

  • Family Fun Night

    The Family Fun Night project began as a Relay for Life fundraiser. As the leadership class continued, I realized that the event could be more than a simple outdoor movie- and that it would need to be more than a simple fundraiser to truly be successful.

    August 13, 2014

  • PA Richards.JPG Richards serving as interim fire chief

    The Olive Hill Fire Department is still facing friction with City Council over ongoing budget concerns. However, the newly appointed interim chief is ready to move forward.

    August 13, 2014 1 Photo