Journal-Times (Grayson, KY)

Columns

March 9, 2011

Bi-partisanship the key to penal code reform

March 9, 2011 —     Frankfort  – Much has been made of the bi-partisan process which produced the General Assembly’s major reform of the state’s penal code.

    That’s as it should be, because the measure is the most significant legislation in years, and Sen. Tom Jensen, Rep. John Tilley and the task force that crafted it demonstrated the best of the legislative process. But it also showed by contrast both how infrequently the process works that way in Frankfort.

    As the task force, the governor, and others gathered Thursday to celebrate passage of the bill, that contrast was obvious. Some who had done little to help – and at least one who had thrown a monkey wrench into the works at the last minute – showed up to take credit. (I don’t mean the Speaker of the House, President of the Senate or the governor. When their times came, they stood up.)

    Everyone talked about how the task force, and especially Tilley and Jensen, worked with stakeholders, sometimes forced compromise, and produced a bi-partisan piece of good policy. Tilley said the process was actually non-partisan.

    But it occurred during a session in which controversial and questionable measures were pushed through with as little debate as possible. Hanging above everything Thursday was an impasse between the Republican Senate on one side and the governor and Democratic House on the other: how to deal with a Medicaid shortfall. Regardless of its merits, the plan put forth by Gov. Steve Beshear and approved by the House was known for weeks. But although most anticipated the general outlines of what the Senate proposed, important details weren’t revealed until last Tuesday night and then quickly passed on the floor the next day along mostly partisan lines.

    Sen. Kathy Stein, D-Lexington, pointed out how little debate occurred on a major bill and that it was passed by the same Republicans who earlier offered a measure to require a 48-hour advance posting of legislation before votes.

    Other bills, like a controversial measure to allow optometrists to perform laser procedures previously restricted to ophthalmologists, were rushed through with as little debate as possible and in the case of the optometry bill, with heavy doses of campaign cash. There have been the usual games of legislative chicken and blackmail, attaching amendments to unrelated bills and gutting one chamber’s bill to replace it with something the other wants but can’t pass in the opposite chamber.

    Clearly the example provided by Tilley and Jensen of what can be done for the state’s citizens didn’t inspire lawmakers to be bi-partisan or non-partisan, engage in open debate or compromise. One Frankfort veteran, a successful lobbyist who has seen several legislative sessions, talked about the contrast late Thursday night.

    He bemoaned the apparent death of a good bill which would protect people from unscrupulous financial predators. Part of the reason, he said, was that some who might be affected by the bill didn’t understand it and feared its consequences – not on those whom it was designed to protect or those who were preying on them – but on third parties who might be inconvenienced.

    “The older I get, the more I realize that we have to talk about these things out in the open, to take the time to make sure everyone understands the bill.”

    Isn’t that a novel idea, considering legislation on its merits and actually doing the public’s business right there in public? Jensen and Tilley showed that works, even on what many thought was an absolutely intractable problem. It’s time others followed their lead.

    RONNIE ELLIS writes for CNHI News Service and is based in Frankfort. Reach him at rellis@cnhi.com.

1
Text Only
Columns
  • Carter County Community Fund is growing

    Great things are happening as people have been working on so many different ways to improve life in Carter County.

    December 18, 2013

  • Lessons learned at church…by chance

    September 25, 2013

  • The acting comeback that never was

    October 17, 2012

  • Questioning proposed budget cuts

    January 26, 2012

  • Where do we draw the line?

    A question from the audience Monday at a Commerce Lexington luncheon illustrates the philosophical conflict for some of today’s conservative right and even for the public at large.

    April 27, 2011

  • Bi-partisanship the key to penal code reform

    Much has been made of the bi-partisan process which produced the General Assembly’s major reform of the state’s penal code.

    March 9, 2011

  • Senate week in review: Medicaid

    This week, we saw some very good legislation and, unfortunately, some very poor legislation moving through the legislative process. Legislation I strongly opposed dealt with a proposed measure to balance the Medicaid budget. Medicaid needs to be fixed – no doubt about that -- but it needs to be fixed with Medicaid money and not by sacrificing education as well as other state programs and jobs.

    March 9, 2011

  • Landmark legislation revamps corrections

    With little time remaining in the 2011 Regular Session, legislators used their time to amend and act on legislation.

    March 9, 2011

  • Legislative week in review

    There was more than one “somewhat unusual coalition” on display last week in Frankfort. That was the description used by Tom Fitzgerald of the Kentucky Resource Council which advocates on environmental issues and usually represents “the little guy.”

    March 2, 2011

  • Legislative action picks up speed in General Assembly

    With only eleven legislative days remaining in this year’s session, our time was used to act on numerous pieces of legislation this week in order to have enough time for the Senate to consider and approve these bills prior to the ten-day veto period.

    March 2, 2011

Poll